Why Rwanda asylum seeker plan is doomed to fail | Letters

All UK taxpayers will to any extent further be complicit in legalised human trafficking, following the disclosing of the federal government plan to fly asylum seekers to Rwanda (UK Rwanda plan for asylum seekers decried as inhumane, costly and lethal, 14 April). Rwanda has a doubtful human rights file. The UK is handing over the protection and human rights of attainable refugees, allegedly persecuted in their very own international locations, to Rwanda, a rustic that in 2010 was among the many 10 lowest-ranked international locations on the earth for press freedom.
Tirthankar Bandyopadhyay
Hounslow, London

History appears to be in peril of repeating itself. In the primary half of the nineteenth century, the Royal Navy was dispatched to west Africa to intercept the cargo of enslaved Africans throughout the Atlantic. Many of the naval initiatives had been thought of unlawful on the time. Those “liberated” by naval motion had been then despatched across the Atlantic world. They got no selection as to the place they’d be “resettled”. Under the coverage, maybe 100,000 Africans had been “rescued” from transatlantic slavery, however an extra 3.5 million had been nonetheless shipped to the Americas between 1807 and 1867, one million of them illegally. One suspects that the UK authorities’s politically motivated scheme will fare no higher in inhibiting the actions of Twenty first-century individuals traffickers.
Prof David Richardson
Wilberforce Institute, University of Hull

As a historian, I used to be reminded of the solutions by a number of Nineteen Thirties British fascist organisations that Jews needs to be exiled to Madagascar. Tory leaders’ contempt in direction of parliament additionally remembers the interwar fascist view of parliamentary democracy as an effete anachronism that could possibly be undermined and outdated. While the Conservative celebration isn’t a fascist celebration, it’s undoubtedly midway down the highway to fascism.
Dr Martin Pugh
Slaley, Northumberland

Having labored in Rwanda, I imagine the Home Office plan will probably be ineffective and poor worth for cash. Many of the individuals crossing the Channel originate from Iran, Iraq and Syria. Culturally, they’re unlikely to combine into Rwandan society, which is of a predominantly Christian custom and has completely different cultural values. In view of Israel’s abortive try at an analogous plan for the resettlement of its African migrants and the closure of the Australia’s offshore processing in Papua New Guinea, it will be folly to proceed.
Dr Joseph Mullen
Former UN adviser to Rwanda

The minister for Brexit alternatives as soon as once more excels in ambiguity (Rwanda asylum plan is ‘almost Easter story of redemption’, says Rees-Mogg, 17 April). Yes, the plan to ship refugees to Rwanda is harking back to some elements of the Easter story. Possibly the half the place an harmless man is arrested, detained, tortured and killed, to fulfill an indignant nationalist mob. And the half the place due authorized course of is deserted to assist an incompetent, amoral administrator out of his private political mire. Yes, a lot like Easter.
Neil Ross
Newark-on-Trent, Nottinghamshire

The authorities claims that sending asylum seekers to Rwanda is a problem to the individuals traffickers’ enterprise mannequin. What subsequent? Take on the mortgage sharks by transferring their victims into workhouses?
Margaret Fowler

Have an opinion on something you’ve learn within the Guardian at present? Please e-mail us your letter and it is going to be thought of for publication.

Source hyperlink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.